Categorizing tumors by cell type and not the organ they grow in may alter treatment, experts say
MONDAY, April 28, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- Women with breast cancer who undergo chemotherapy are more likely to end up unemployed than patients who get other treatments, a new study reports.
The study of women younger than 65 found that four years after treatment for early stage breast cancer, more than one-third who had chemotherapy were out of work compared to just over one-quarter of women who had other treatments.
"Many of us realize the chemotherapy is going to knock the wind out of your sails temporarily. We [as doctors] have tended to assume women bounced back, and the results here suggest that's not the case," said study researcher Dr. Reshma Jagsi, associate professor and associate chair of radiation oncology at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor.
Along with gains in breast cancer survival comes a responsibility for experts to look at treatment effects on a person's life and livelihood, Jagsi said.
The long-term link with unemployment surprised her, Jagsi said, although she noted that the study doesn't establish a direct cause-and-effect relationship between the drug therapy for early stage breast cancer and later job loss.
For the study, published online April 28 in Cancer, Jagsi and her colleagues evaluated data from U.S. registries on women diagnosed with early stage breast cancer between 2005 and 2007. They sent surveys to over 3,000 women right after diagnosis and four years later.
The study authors focused on the 746 women under age 65 who answered both surveys and who worked for pay before their cancer diagnosis.
Of these, 30 percent were unemployed at the four-year follow-up, although many said they wanted to work and were job-hunting.
Jagsi's team then looked at the type of treatment and whether it had a bearing on employment status. Those who received chemotherapy were 1.4 times more likely to be unemployed than those who didn't have that treatment, the investigators found.
Thirty-eight percent of the chemotherapy patients were unemployed four years later versus 27 percent of those who didn't get chemo. That difference was statistically significant.
The study didn't go into the reasons for job loss, but Jagsi had some ideas. "It may be that they are experiencing long-term side effects, like nerve problems that can happen after certain kinds of chemotherapy, that can make it hard to drive a bus or type on a keyboard," she said.
Another possibility: "In the current economy, it's really hard to keep your job or get it back after you've missed a lot of work or stopped working during treatment," she said.
Other research has found that cancer survivors can experience long-term "chemo brain" -- a kind of mental fogginess -- after chemotherapy.
The other take-home message from her study, Jagsi said, is that women must become advocates for themselves and their careers. They should talk to the doctor in depth about the range of treatments and the pros and cons of each, she explained.
"In some cases, the marginal benefit of chemotherapy beyond all the other wonderful treatments we have is relatively small," she said. "And it may be that when all potential downsides are considered -- including potential long-term effects on employment -- that some women will decide that this benefit doesn't outweigh the risks."
The study findings point to an important issue, agreed Susan Brown, managing director of health and science education for the Susan G. Komen for the Cure, an advocacy organization. "Quality of life after breast cancer treatment is of key importance," she said.
Currently, "we are not aware that employment implications are something that are generally considered at the time of treatment," Brown said.
Tools such as tumor profiling tests that indicate recurrence risk might help patients and their doctors make informed treatment decisions, she added.
"We encourage all women and men facing breast cancer to have a discussion with their health care provider, and discuss any treatment-related concerns they may have," Brown said.
To learn more about chemotherapy, visit the U.S. National Cancer Institute.
SOURCES: Susan Brown, M.S., R.N., managing director, health and science education, Susan G. Komen for the Cure; Reshma Jagsi, M.D., D.Phil., associate professor and associate chair, radiation oncology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor; April 28, 2014, Cancer, online
Copyright © 2014 HealthDay. All rights reserved.
Wed Apr 30, 2014 07:45 PM
If women took time off for chemo and recovery, they likely lost their old job. The only women I know who did not lose their jobs when they took time off for chemo and healing, were flight attendants, teachers, and other government employees who were protected by their respecitve unions.
Wed Apr 30, 2014 09:13 PM
I am one of those women who lost their job (I worked up till the hysterectomy when my position was eliminated) and I still am unable to work. It was recommended that I take a very aggressive approach for my early stage BC IIIA Her 2+. I had a right mastectomy, took 6 mos. Chemo, 7 weeks Radiation, 1 year Herceptin. I also had to have a hysterectomy and I am still on Arimidex now 8 yrs from my initial diagnosis in 2006. I also was declined for diability even though I have worked sinced I was 17 years old. I now have chronic lymphedema, Short -term memory issues, neuropathy & chronic fibromyalgia from the combined treatments......but guess what?? I am still here so yes the benefits of life out weighs the risks. But I do think our Government, Employers and even some Doctors need to be more considerate in what any Cancer Survivor must go through & endure to be alive. I still would not change a thing for the time I have with my husband, family & friends.
We care about your feedback. Let us know how we can improve your CancerCompass experience.