Average Rating:Rating
Rate this Discussion: rate!

When Should One Consider A Hysterectomy

Switch to Single View
Records 1-5 of 5
Subject: When should one consider a hysterectomy
Date: 08/22/2007

My prayers are with those in the midst of this. I am sorry if my question seems unimportant. I have had ovarian cancer in my family. My count just went over the acceptable measure, not by much 37, but my question is, as a 50yr old with no children and not expecting any last minute miracles, should I have a hysterectomy?

 I have a great nurse practitioner and we took another test and then if still high will go for another ultrasound-I took one my mother was diagnosed so I'd have a baseline.

Any advise? Thank you and I'm sorry for taking time fromyour more serious concerns.

Karen

Subject: RE: When should one consider a hysterectomy
Date: 08/23/2007
Hi Karen, my thinking is, why wait.  If my doc would of done a total hyst 8 yrs ago instead of part I may have never had cancer. But then again one never knows. If your having problems and your looking into it, do it, but thats just my thoughts.  Good luck
Subject: RE: When should one consider a hysterectomy
Date: 08/23/2007

Hello, good question. I have no family history of ovca. I had lots of cyst issues and endometriosis. I opted at 42 to have a TOH because we decided years before that we did not want children. I was very lucky--my cancer was discovered Stage 1.... none of my doctors or I suspected anything. If you get 2nd, 3rd opinions and the option seems like a good prophylactic decision.... you must decide what is best for you. Blessings!

Subject: RE: When should one consider a hysterectomy
Date: 08/23/2007
did the women in your family have BRCA testing? If not, I would suggest you look into that.  It's a blood test.  The BRCA 1 and 2 genes are inherited genes.  If you have them you are at very high risk for breast cancer and at somewhat lower risk for ovarian cancer.  Most ovarian cancer is not inherited; however, if you have a family hx it is good to check this out.
Doctor / Nurse
Doctor / Nurse
dr Steve
Recommend this Message
Subject: RE: When should one consider a hysterectomy
Date: 08/24/2007

Hi.  Actually this is a very good question for this forum since prevention always beats treatment.

I am assuming you mean your CA125 is 37.  Please know that this test is completely useless as a screening tool.  Ultrasound is not much better.  Research is ongoing and we will likely have a better tool within 2-3 years. For now, neither Ultrasound nor CA125 has saved any lives.  There have been reports here and there of heartwarming outcomes, but that is not the reality of the overwhelming majority of good medical studies published. 

With a family history you should see a genetics counselor who will likely recommend BRCA testing.  As an alternative, find a gynecologic oncologist.

Removing the uterus is not that important.  It is the ovaries that are of concern in your situation. Those can be removed with minimal risk via laparoscopy( minimally invasive surgery).  The uterus is usually an innocent bystander, but you can discuss the risk vs benefit of removing it along with your ovaries once it is clear that you should have the ovaries removed.

No surgery is riskless, so you should have a good solid reason for having any done. You may very well have a good reason, but that is why you should start with a genetics consultation as soon as possible.

Regards.

Dr V  www.gyncancerdoctor.com   

Records 1-5 of 5
Switch to Single View
close




Sending...
Required Fields All fields are required.
close
User is No longer Ignored
Show messages from this user
close
Report Abuse
Anonymous Note to Administrator:

Reporting
Latest Messages Show More
RE: How long to stay on T Posted by Mullymax on 07/09 08:05:10 AM
RE: Just diagnosed - scar Posted by jcr65566 on 07/09 08:01:21 AM
RE: diet Posted by Craig57 on 07/09 07:56:48 AM
Sun spots and chemo quest Posted by blins00 on 07/09 07:43:00 AM
RE: what is....? Posted by Craig57 on 07/09 07:39:02 AM
RE: Revlimid and anaemia Posted by Summerday on 07/09 07:32:59 AM
RE: my dog and love has b Posted by Mariahs Mommie on 07/09 07:26:43 AM
RE: NEXAVAR 200 MG Posted by kelliejo2 on 07/09 07:23:08 AM
RE: diet Posted by tongrenhealer on 07/09 07:01:15 AM
RE: how to choose about s Posted by Flower1 on 07/09 06:47:50 AM
RE: And So Life Carries o Posted by Anniedips on 07/09 06:33:06 AM
Bladder Cancer - 3D Medical Animation