Average Rating:Rating
Rate this Discussion: rate!

Hdr Monotherapy

Switch to Single View
Records 1-5 of 5
Subject: HDR MONOTHERAPY
Date: 10/28/2007

Gleason 6,  PSA  5.6 , T2b, 64 years old in excellent health considering HDR Monotherapy at CET Cancer Center in Oakland Ca. . Would appreciate hearing from anyone who has had HDR and what side effects they have expereinced.  thanks - Rob from Oregon

Doctor / Nurse
Doctor / Nurse
Witchdoctor
Recommend this Message
Subject: RE: HDR MONOTHERAPY
Date: 10/29/2007

You are a candidate for any treatment from surgery to low dose implant.

My decision would be based on side effects , morbidity /mortality etc.

In HDR would they treat you in one session or would you have to to be implanted two or more times?

If they have to do multiple procedures I would go with Low dose brachy or external beam.  One procedure or No procedure.  The results are good whatever you do but the lowest longterm sequelae is with external beam and salvage of any local recurrence with surgery or implant is possible.

Subject: RE: HDR MONOTHERAPY
Date: 10/29/2007

 

On 10/29/2007 Witchdoctor wrote:

You are a candidate for any treatment from surgery to low dose implant.

My decision would be based on side effects , morbidity /mortality etc.

In HDR would they treat you in one session or would you have to to be implanted two or more times?

If they have to do multiple procedures I would go with Low dose brachy or external beam.  One procedure or No procedure.  The results are good whatever you do but the lowest longterm sequelae is with external beam and salvage of any local recurrence with surgery or implant is possible.


The HDR treatments would involve 3 treatments with an overnight stay in the hospital. A week later the proceedure would be repeated. CET is very selective in approving canditates for the HDR Monotherapy,  and their success rate exceeds 95% with few side effects. I do not understand why more more cancer centers do not offer it.

 

Doctor / Nurse
Doctor / Nurse
Witchdoctor
Recommend this Message
Subject: RE: HDR MONOTHERAPY
Date: 10/31/2007
It involves two nights in the hospital, two procedures, two anesthesias and the results are not any better than other methods.  Probably more expensive as well when all charges are added.  The acute and long term side effects are more frequent due to the procedures and lastly it is more time intensive for the physicians.  You sound more like a seller than someone undergoing the procedure.
Doctor / Nurse
Doctor / Nurse
Oncrx
Recommend this Message
Subject: RE: HDR MONOTHERAPY
Date: 10/31/2007

Witchdoc

would it be fair to say that monotherapy is relatively new while the combination of HDR plus external beam has a proven track record with very high success rates and relatively low side effect rates in certain select patients ?

Records 1-5 of 5
Switch to Single View
close




Sending...
Required Fields All fields are required.
close
User is No longer Ignored
Show messages from this user
close
Report Abuse
Anonymous Note to Administrator:

Reporting
Latest Messages Show More
RE: SEVERE HOT FLASHES du Posted by poppy/cath on 07/09 12:48:52 AM
RE: signet ring cell Posted by computerpals on 07/09 12:42:38 AM
RE: Just diagnosed - scar Posted by thinkpositive2050 on 07/09 12:39:57 AM
RE: signet ring cell Posted by computerpals on 07/09 12:36:41 AM
RE: Urgent Help!!! Please Posted by computerpals on 07/09 12:33:00 AM
RE: Primary Peritoneal Ca Posted by Larryv2.0 on 07/09 12:32:07 AM
To stop stomach/bowel cra Posted by computerpals on 07/09 12:30:02 AM
RE: my biopsy results Posted by whdigital on 07/09 12:29:51 AM
Peritoneal cancer Posted by Larryv2.0 on 07/09 12:28:07 AM
RE: Help pls- what is cau Posted by computerpals on 07/09 12:25:00 AM
RE: Help pls- what is cau Posted by computerpals on 07/09 12:23:56 AM
Prostate Cancer - 3D Medical Animation