Average Rating:Rating
Rate this Discussion: rate!

Biopsy Second Opinion

Switch to Single View
Records 1-5 of 5
Subject: Biopsy Second Opinion
Date: 03/11/2008

Was diagnosed with PC  1-1/2 years ago with 10 needle biopsy and pc in 10% of one core and GS = 10.   I have been WW since that time and PSA has stayed low,  around 1.   I had a second biopsy several weeks ago and go the results today,  benign and PIN in two of 12 needles, no tumors observed.   This leads to more questions than answers. 

I'm not comfortable with the lastest Path report and would like to get a second opinion.  Also,  I never got a second opinion on the first test results 1.5 years ago,  is it to late to get a 2nd opinion on that test? 

Does anyone have any recommendations for a good Pathologist and how do you go about this?  Do I just contact a good Cancer center like MD Anderson or John Hopkins and ask them for a second opinion or does my Urologist do this?  Does Medicare pay for second opinions?                       Thanks for your help.

 

Subject: RE: Biopsy Second Opinion
Date: 03/12/2008

Dear friend, although I am sorry that I'm unable to answer most of your questions, I can tell you that my brother didn't have any recommendations from a doctor when he went to The Anderson Cancer Center in Houston, TX. for a second opinion.was diagnoised with prostate cancer. He went on the internet to  get the info. that he  needed, called down there and they set everything up for him.  You can  type in Anderson Cancer Center on the computor, and it will bring up all kinds of info.

My brothers  insusrance paid  for the medical procedures there, however he is not on medicare yet, but I presume that medicare would do the same, but it would be wise to check with your insurance carrier as well as the Anderson Cancer Center.  Unfortunately Insurance. at least his does not pay for transportation there and back, or for hotel, food etc.   Sorry I couldn't be of more help, but hope that this info. will help alittle.

                                                                          

On 3/11/2008 danbFla wrote:

Was diagnosed with PC  1-1/2 years ago with 10 needle biopsy and pc in 10% of one core and GS = 10.   I have been WW since that time and PSA has stayed low,  around 1.   I had a second biopsy several weeks ago and go the results today,  benign and PIN in two of 12 needles, no tumors observed.   This leads to more questions than answers. 

I'm not comfortable with the lastest Path report and would like to get a second opinion.  Also,  I never got a second opinion on the first test results 1.5 years ago,  is it to late to get a 2nd opinion on that test? 

Does anyone have any recommendations for a good Pathologist and how do you go about this?  Do I just contact a good Cancer center like MD Anderson or John Hopkins and ask them for a second opinion or does my Urologist do this?  Does Medicare pay for second opinions?                       Thanks for your help.

 


 

Subject: RE: Biopsy Second Opinion
Date: 03/12/2008

Your Urologist will send them to JH or wherever you direct.

Survivor
Survivor
john1a
(1) Member
recommended this message
Recommend this Message
Subject: RE: Biopsy Second Opinion
Date: 03/13/2008
Go to drslawin.com He was actually my 3rd opinion -- fantastic folks there. Slawin was with Baylor and is now with Vanguard. Look him up.

On 3/11/2008 danbFla wrote:

Was diagnosed with PC  1-1/2 years ago with 10 needle biopsy and pc in 10% of one core and GS = 10.   I have been WW since that time and PSA has stayed low,  around 1.   I had a second biopsy several weeks ago and go the results today,  benign and PIN in two of 12 needles, no tumors observed.   This leads to more questions than answers. 

I'm not comfortable with the lastest Path report and would like to get a second opinion.  Also,  I never got a second opinion on the first test results 1.5 years ago,  is it to late to get a 2nd opinion on that test? 

Does anyone have any recommendations for a good Pathologist and how do you go about this?  Do I just contact a good Cancer center like MD Anderson or John Hopkins and ask them for a second opinion or does my Urologist do this?  Does Medicare pay for second opinions?                       Thanks for your help.

 


Subject: RE: Biopsy Second Opinion
Date: 03/13/2008

 

On 3/11/2008 danbFla wrote:

Was diagnosed with PC  1-1/2 years ago with 10 needle biopsy and pc in 10% of one core and GS = 10.   I have been WW since that time and PSA has stayed low,  around 1.   I had a second biopsy several weeks ago and go the results today,  benign and PIN in two of 12 needles, no tumors observed.   This leads to more questions than answers. 

I'm not comfortable with the lastest Path report and would like to get a second opinion.  Also,  I never got a second opinion on the first test results 1.5 years ago,  is it to late to get a 2nd opinion on that test? 

Does anyone have any recommendations for a good Pathologist and how do you go about this?  Do I just contact a good Cancer center like MD Anderson or John Hopkins and ask them for a second opinion or does my Urologist do this?  Does Medicare pay for second opinions?                       Thanks for your help.

 

Hi
danbFla,

    In response to your message:as far as your pathology report I don't have any answer to that.  As for as a second opinion; I was diagnosed last July with PC and Medicare paid for a second opinion. I just used my pathology report from my diagnosis and let the second opinion doctor follow up with that information.  On my pathology report there was one pathologist that done the report and a second pathologist agreed with his finds.

    It would seem strange to me that the second report didn't show any cancer when the first one did. I can see why you have questions.  

I hope this was helpful. 

 

Records 1-5 of 5
Switch to Single View
close




Sending...
Required Fields All fields are required.
close
User is No longer Ignored
Show messages from this user
close
Report Abuse
Anonymous Note to Administrator:

Reporting
Latest Messages Show More
RE: DIPG Con Job Posted by jcr65566 on 07/24 03:45:04 PM
RE: Othe Options Posted by Mike47 on 07/24 03:44:35 PM
RE: Weight Gain/loss Whil Posted by POOTERSDOG on 07/24 03:29:58 PM
RE: Fear of recheck testi Posted by chef4u on 07/24 03:29:53 PM
RE: Biopsy Posted by prncessem on 07/24 03:27:54 PM
Fear of recheck testing Posted by Darcy r on 07/24 03:20:33 PM
RE: papillary is aggressi Posted by W3spal on 07/24 03:17:44 PM
RE: DIPG Con Job Posted by raaven on 07/24 03:09:07 PM
RE: For those of you havi Posted by W3spal on 07/24 03:06:59 PM
RE: Extreme Exhaustion Posted by chef4u on 07/24 03:05:33 PM
RE: Don't know what to te Posted by Dlynn1210 on 07/24 02:10:34 PM
Cancer Resource Center