Laproscopic vs standard surgery

1 Posts | Page(s): 1 

Laproscopic vs standard surgery

by Bob_S on Fri Jan 02, 2009 12:00 AM

Quote | Reply

 

      Hi:

     You know sometimes I'm skeptical about the fact that the majority

     of thoracic surgeons do push the standard procedures of doing an

     IV operation while shying away from the laproscopic method.The

    question in my mind is ; are they doing this because they

   don't have the proper training & experience in laproscopic or are

  the current standard methods truly superior? They claim that

 they have a better chance of removing all of the cancer with the

 standard methods than they do through the laproscopic method.

 What can they see when they open someone up that they can't

 see through a pet scan? Additionally, if a pet scan can not detect

a cancerous spot that is smaller than a dime, what is the surgeon

likely to see with his/her human eyesight? I can see the necessity

of the standard procedure if the scans detect a metastic situation

to other organs but suppose it's only a one or a few lymph nodes?

Why cant this be done on a minimally invasive basis?

 This whole approach by the medical community in general when

 it does come down to esophageal surgery does provide a need

to have some additional clarification & insight for patients.

Are we being denied certain options because of the lack of

skill and training on the part of the doctors? I inquired about

having laproscopic surgery done by a certain doctor on a 3cm

--1 lymph node situation--his response was----"naahh! I want to get

 in there and see what's going on".What the hell is that supposed

 to mean? I'm supposed to accept that? These people aren't gods.

 They make many errors-particularly when it comes to prognosis.

 I'm reading more & more about docs who are performing

 sucessful lapro surgeries for esophageal cancer.Is this all

 baloney or is it that it's easier for the docs to do the standard

 operational procedure rather than to go out there and get the

 additional training?     

Any opinions?--------Bob S.

1 Posts | Page(s): 1 
Subscribe to this message board discussion

Latest Messages

CancerCompass Poll

How often do you use a mobile device (e.g., iPhone, Blackberry, etc.) to access the internet?

We care about your feedback. Let us know how we can improve your CancerCompass experience.