On 6/8/2009
jpoobah wrote:
Steve,
So happy to hear that you wife is doing well all this time. I was wondering if her treament has included surgery or just chemo and or radiation? My mom has responded well to chemo and radiation after being diagnosed with Stage 4 in Nov 08, but now the recomendation is a complete gastronectomy now that the tumor has been reduced in size.
Just trying to find if just fighting it with chemo and radiation is being done w/o surgery. Seems that the recomendations are for surgery in any case where it is possible, did you get that adivce as well?
Thanks in advance for anything you can share.
Thanks,
Jpoobah
Jpoobah:
Back in April of 07 when originally diagnosed the oncologist recommended surgery but then we found out it had spread to a single spot in her liver and she went on ECF chemo. Post three months both tumors had disappeared and they again considered surgery; however our third opinion from Sloan Kettering strongly recommended against that procedure (partial removal of stomach) and instead recommended continued chemotherapy as the tumors had responded so well to the treatment. Therefore, no surgery and she has continued on the chemotherapy. With her case you must be aware that although it had spread we caught if very early and both tumors were small 3-4cm. She had received no radiation as it was not necessary since the chemo killed all the cancer cells. The theory behind continued chemo was since it had spread to the liver, it could be anywhere and the chemo is the only weapon that can deliver effective treatment throughout the body.
Surgergical interventions seem to be used in cases like yours where the main tumor site has been affected by the chemo (tumor is shrinking) but does not completely destroy the tumor and thus the theory is that by removing the main threat and treating with chemo after you have removed the main threat and then address the possibility of cancer cells being in other places with the chemo. Also, by reducing the tumor size it tells us that the cancer is reacting to the chemo being administered.
Either way, the surgery is a major surgery and a personal one. I would definately get at least one second opinion prior to a surgical intervention. WE have received opionions during our ordeal from:
Hartford Hospital (this is where she is treated)
Sloan Kettering / Dana Farber / Columbia (NY) / and Yale New Haven
All these opinions have given us important insight into different recommendations however, in the end, the decision lies with the patient and their family.
Get at least one more opinion and drive the process; dont wait for appointments really push it. These are busy people but you have decisions to make and you need their advice. Also remember to have a copy of all your diagnostic tests and oncology notes (get a whole copy of your oncology file) and send it to them in advance so you do not wast time and you can refer to your own copy to ensure they looked at everything.
Good luck with your decision, it is a difficult one. Get another opinion. Be glad that the tumor is responding to the treatment.
Steve aka momwithkids