Average Rating:Rating
Rate this Discussion: rate!

Very Different Results At 2 Different Labs?? Anyone Else?

Expand all Messages
Caregiver
Caregiver
1worriedwife
Recommend this Message
Subject: Very different results at 2 different labs?? Anyone else?
Date: 02/05/2008

Hello.

 My husband, was diagnosed (we not sure the dx is correct until we see a myeloma specialist, but....) with SMM in Nov 2006 was recently hospitalized with sepsis/bacterimia. He picked up the bacteria 'strep pneumoniae) in his sinuses, and it went to his bloodstream. A week on IV antibiotics, and it's cleared up, though still being rechecked weekly.

While in the hospital, they also ran an SPEP, knowing his MGUS/SMM history.  Interesting result...

Let my start by saying that outpatient, we always use the same lab (Quest). His IGg's have been (since 2006) 2460, 2550, 2612, 2880 (6 weeks before hospitalization). At the hospital lab, we were told that his IGg's dropped to 2200! 

How different can labs be? Could it have dropped due to the infection? I would think that the antibodies being produced to fight the infection would have raised it, but I'm not sure about that. He's been on curcumin for 3 months (8g/day), and we were hoping for  drop, but this seems too good to be true!

Anyone have experience with how different lab results can be at different labs? Then the question I want to ask is - so which one is right??? If the hospital lab is, he may not have SMM at all. That's been based only on his IGg levels increasing, while IGa and Igm decreased. (bone marrow results were 10% even, right on the line...).

Could it have been affected by his illness? I'd love to have it done again when he's well by both labs in a similar timeframe. However, our insurance will only pay for one lab, and I understand that the SPEP is a bit pricey....

Any suggestions?  I asked the oncologist who visited him (once) in the hospital and got nowhere. He spent 5 minutes smiling & nodding, telling us nothing! He did tell us the IGg's had gone down to 2200. I said, "that's good, right?", and he just shrugged and smiled!  I asked what the total protein level was, and he said it was up to 8.9 (it wasn't, it was  8.6 per the hosp records I got). I asked what the M-spike was, and he got very angry, and said that he hadn't had a chance to review the chart, and walked out! And for that he's probably going to charge our insurance $300!  Needless to say, we won't be seeing that oncologist again (and yes, he is the HEAD of Oncology at this particular hospital, but we're a small area, and if his whole practice of 7 docs has 15 myeloma patients, I'd be surprised). 

So what has been anyone's experience with fluctuations in lab tests??

1 worried wife

 

Messages History for "Very Different Results At 2 Different Labs?? Anyone Else?"

  1. Very different results at 2 different labs?? Anyone else?
  2. RE: Very different results at 2 different labs?? Anyone else?
  3. RE: Very different results at 2 different labs?? Anyone else?
  4. RE: Very different results at 2 different labs?? Anyone else?
Expand all Messages
close




Sending...
Required Fields All fields are required.
close
User is No longer Ignored
Show messages from this user
close
Report Abuse
Anonymous Note to Administrator:

Reporting
Latest Messages Show More
RE: xeloda as maintenance Posted by Lauri on 09/07 11:32:13 PM
RE: vitamin C iv infusion Posted by johnsc on 09/07 11:21:34 PM
RE: His final sleep Posted by SCORPIO on 09/07 11:00:45 PM
RE: Can you help please Posted by allienz on 09/07 10:59:43 PM
RE: Can you help please Posted by allienz on 09/07 10:56:49 PM
RE: Help for a friend Posted by Louzda on 09/07 10:56:40 PM
RE: Sutent Users Posted by EagleGirl on 09/07 10:52:13 PM
RE: anyone try any natura Posted by mmsurvivor on 09/07 10:36:28 PM
RE: No treatment/no hope? Posted by Twiddles on 09/07 10:21:51 PM
RE: what lies ahead for u Posted by Daughters Love on 09/07 10:07:05 PM
Reoccurrance Posted by pupanyc on 09/07 10:02:58 PM
Prostate Cancer - 3D Medical Animation