Many Cancer Patients Take Alternative Meds But Don't Tell Their Doctors

health day

THURSDAY, April 11, 2019 (HealthDay News) -- One out of every three U.S. cancer patients uses alternative or complementary therapies, but many keep that info from their doctors, a new study finds.

That's a real concern, the study's lead author said, especially when it comes to supplements and cancer radiation therapy.

"You don't know what's in them," said Dr. Nina Sanford, assistant professor of radiation oncology at UT Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas.

"Some of these supplements are kind of a mishmash of different things," she said. "Unless we know what's in them, I would recommend patients avoid using them during radiation because there's likely not data on certain supplements, which could interfere with treatment. With radiation specifically, there is concern that very high levels of antioxidants could make radiation less effective."

The new study looked at U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data on over 3,100 cancer patients. Sanford's team found that herbal supplements were the most common complementary and alternative therapy used by cancer patients, followed by chiropractic.

Other therapies include meditation, yoga and acupuncture.

The study also found that 29% of patients who use complementary and alternative therapies did not tell their doctor.

"Younger patients are more likely to use complementary and alternative medicines, and women were more likely to, but I would have thought more people would tell their doctors," Sanford said in a UT Southwestern news release.

Why the secrecy? Many patients said they didn't inform their doctors because their doctors didn't ask, or because they thought their doctors didn't need to know they were using alternative or complementary therapies.

But physicians do need to know if cancer patients are using herbal products because they can alter traditional cancer treatments, explained Dr. David Gerber. He is a lung cancer specialist and professor of internal medicine and population and data sciences at UT Southwestern Medical Center.

"They may interact with the medicines we're giving them, and through that interaction it could alter the level of the medicine in the patient," he said in the news release. "If the levels get too high, then toxicities increase, and if the levels get too low, the efficacy would drop."

Dr. John Ames directs radiation medicine at Northwell Health's Imbert Cancer Center in Bay Shore, N.Y. He wasn't involved in the new study, but said the findings ring true.

"As a practicing radiation oncologist for nearly 30 years, I have witnessed the evolution -- indeed, revolution -- of alternative health practices, such as the healing arts of meditation, yoga and the like, and the use of herbals and supplements among cancer patients," he said.

Ames believes the use of these therapies has now "become mainstream in our society."

"Anecdotally, I am asked by at least half of my patients, 'can I take,' 'should I take,' 'is it OK if I am taking supplements' while undergoing conventional cancer therapies," he noted.

Ames urges his patients to be upfront about whatever complementary medicines they might be taking.

"If supplements/herbals/nutraceuticals are to be used, I caution my patients to obtain them from reputable sources and do their homework, which includes asking questions from knowledgeable individuals," he said. Patients should also "be wary of the financial toxicity of expensive supplements with overblown or little, to no, real benefit," he added.

Sanford added that, while wary of herbal products, doctors are open to meditation and yoga to help patients cope with the shock of a cancer diagnosis and the stress of chemotherapy, radiation and surgery.

"We strongly advise patients to stay active and engage in exercise during treatment," Sanford said. "A common side effect of radiation is fatigue. I let the patients know that the patients who feel the most fatigue are the ones who are the most sedentary, and that those who are doing exercise are the ones who frequently have the most energy."

Ames agreed.

He said he typically advises his patients "to eat and drink healthy, nutritious food (the specifics of which are outlined by the nutritionists on our staff); to stay well-hydrated; stay active (exercise) within their ability; and to engage in relaxing, calming, restorative activities as often as possible -- quality sleep being chief among them."

The study was published online April 11 in the journal JAMA Oncology.

More information

The U.S. National Cancer Institute has more on complementary and alternative therapies.

SOURCES: John W. Ames, M.D., physician in chief, department of radiation medicine, Northwell Health's Imbert Cancer Center, Bay Shore, N.Y.; UT Southwestern Medical Center, news release, April 11, 2019

Copyright © 2019 HealthDay. All rights reserved.



Thu Apr 18, 2019 05:33 PM

My radiation oncologist told me not to take anything while I was in treatment.  He offered a different reason:  anything that is good for normal cells might be extra good for cancer cells, which have an ability to make the most of the nutrition a cancer patient gets.  And that reason alone was enough for me, but the ones given in this article add strength to the prohibition.  I wasn't even to take a multivitamin for this reason.


Fri Apr 19, 2019 12:46 AM

Most doctor favor only what they prescribe for business reasons. So if you tell your doctor that you take something they did not prescribed, naturaly they will be against. They are still arguing if vitamin C is good  or not for patients. is just business. Also most of them do not give nutritional advice.

Fri Apr 19, 2019 06:56 PM

Much of this article is true but what is missing is the fact that our medical education and training system does not teach doctors about these alternatives. Thus for their own protection they will always recomend not using anything they haven't been trained in! Many of these supplements can enhance these therapies or even reduce the negative side effects, but they need to be studied and taught to our profesionals.I agree without knowledge caution should be applied so lets get the knowledge and take advantage of the possible benefits these can offer!

You must be logged in to post comments.

We care about your feedback. Let us know how we can improve your CancerCompass experience.